Deck Replacement and Repair
Deck Replacement and Repair
Services in Ardmore
GET FREE ESTIMATE
Whether you are starting from scratch and want a beautiful new outdoor living space, you have an aging deck that has reached the end of its useful life and needs full replacement, or you have a structurally sound deck with specific damage that needs professional repair, Hynes Construction handles all three. For homeowners looking for Deck Service in Ardmore, we have been building, replacing, and repairing decks on Ardmore homes for over 50 years, and we know the specific conditions that Ardmore’s housing stock, climate, and tree canopy create for every category of deck work.
Three core services, clearly defined: Deck installation means building a new deck where one did not exist. Deck replacement means tearing out an existing structure and building a completely new one in its place. Deck repair means fixing identified problems on a deck whose overall structure remains sound. Each requires a different assessment, a different scope of work, and a different decision process. We will help you identify exactly which one applies to your situation.
Quick links: Deck services overview | Free estimate | Financing options | Warranties | Project gallery | Certifications | About us.
Deck installation in Ardmore means starting from the ground up on a home that has never had a deck or building a deck addition in a previously unused area of the property. This is the most involved of the three deck services because it requires full design development, impervious surface calculation, permit application, footing installation, structural framing, and surface installation as a complete sequence.
Ardmore is split between Lower Merion Township in Montgomery County and Haverford Township in Delaware County. The permit requirements differ between the two municipalities, and your address determines which applies. Both require building permits for attached decks and elevated decks over 30 inches. Both count as impervious surfaces, which limits how large you can build on your lot. Both have zoning setback requirements from property lines that constrain deck placement.
Lower Merion Township: Permits processed through the Building and Planning Department at 610-645-6200. Applications require a plot plan, setback compliance verification, impervious surface calculation, signed contract, and permit compliance form. Lower Merion adopted the 2021 International Residential Code effective January 2026 with updated ledger connection, post-sizing, and railing height requirements.
Haverford Township: Permits through the Building and Codes Department. Contractors must be licensed with Haverford Township. Applications require a plot plan with property markers, building coverage, and impervious surface ratio calculations, and a certificate of insurance naming Haverford Township as the certificate holder.
Hynes Construction handles all permitting for both municipalities as part of every deck installation. We calculate your lot’s specific impervious surface allowance and verify setback compliance before you commit to any design, because finding out your dream deck cannot be permitted after you have fallen in love with it is an avoidable frustration.
This is the planning constraint that surprises most Ardmore homeowners. Both Lower Merion Township and Haverford Township count decks as impervious surface, meaning adding a deck uses up part of your lot’s maximum coverage allowance. If your property is already at or near its zoning maximum from your house footprint, driveway, existing patios, and other improvements, the size of the new deck you can build may be constrained even if the physical backyard space is available.
Previous decking designs, those with wider board gaps and permeable materials, may partially reduce the impervious surface calculation in certain Lower Merion zoning situations. We evaluate this opportunity for every project. We also help you prioritize what outdoor improvements make the most sense within your allowance if the full deck footprint you initially envisioned exceeds what the lot allows.
Deck installation costs in the Philadelphia area range from $30 to $70 per square foot for the complete project, including materials, labor, permits, and footings. Here is a realistic breakdown for Ardmore:
According to the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report for the Philadelphia region, wood decks deliver approximately 90 percent ROI at resale and composite decks approximately 87 percent, both far above national averages. For an Ardmore home with a median value of over $597,000, a new deck is one of the highest-return exterior investments available. See our financing options if the upfront cost requires support.
Composite decking (Trex and TimberTech): The leading choice for most Ardmore homeowners because of the dense tree canopy creating shaded, moist backyard conditions where wood deteriorates faster than in sunnier environments. Composite resists mold, rot, and moisture far better than natural wood. Requires only occasional cleaning. 25-year or longer manufacturer warranties.
Pressure-treated wood: Delivers the highest immediate ROI at resale and lower upfront cost. Requires cleaning and restaining every two to three years. Best choice when maximizing immediate sale value or when budget constraints favor lower upfront investment.
Cedar and premium hardwoods: Cedar’s natural tannins provide inherent rot and insect resistance without chemical treatment. Appropriate for Ardmore’s architectural styles and requires somewhat less frequent restaining than pressure-treated pine. Tropical hardwoods like ipe offer a 25-year or more lifespan with minimal maintenance at a premium cost.
Deck replacement means completely removing an existing deck structure down to the footings, assessing whether the footings can be reused or need replacement, and building an entirely new deck in their place. It is different from deck repair in that the decision has been made that the existing structure is not worth preserving, either because of the extent of structural damage, the cost comparison against repair, or the desire to redesign the space entirely.
The most important decision in any deck project is correctly identifying whether you are dealing with a repair situation or a replacement situation. Here is how to tell:
Use the screwdriver test on any wood component you can access. Healthy wood resists a screwdriver. If you can push a screwdriver more than one-quarter inch into a post, beam, joist, or ledger board with minimal resistance, the wood is rotted. Surface rot on deck boards is often a repair situation. Rot at the structural level, in posts, beams, the ledger board connecting the deck to your home, or the main supporting joists, is almost always a replacement situation. Repairing structural rot piecemeal on an older Ardmore deck often costs nearly as much as replacement while leaving other deteriorating components in place.
A deck that moves noticeably underfoot has compromised structural integrity at the framing or footing level. This is a safety issue, not a cosmetic one. The cause is typically rotted joists, failing ledger board attachment, deteriorated post bases, or footings that have heaved or settled through Pennsylvania’s freeze-thaw cycles. These are structural failures that require full replacement of the affected components at a minimum, and full deck replacement is often the more practical and cost-effective answer.
Pressure-treated wood decks in Pennsylvania’s climate typically last 15 to 25 years with proper maintenance. Cedar decks can last 20 to 30 years. If your Ardmore deck is approaching or past 20 years old, the structural components, including joists, beams, and posts, have likely reached the end of their service life, even if surface boards look acceptable. An aging frame that requires the replacement of multiple components at once is usually better addressed with full replacement than serial repairs.
This is the practical financial threshold. If the total cost to repair all identified damage on your existing Ardmore deck approaches or exceeds 50 percent of what a complete replacement would cost, replacement almost always delivers better long-term value. You get a full warranty on all new materials, compliance with current code requirements, the opportunity to redesign the space, and no ongoing concern about the deteriorating components you chose not to replace.
Pest damage to wood framing components is not a repair situation. Even after pest control treatment, wood that has been tunneled through by termites or carpenter ants has compromised load-bearing capacity. Full replacement is the only appropriate response to structural pest damage on an Ardmore deck.
The ledger board is the most structurally critical component of an attached deck. It is the connection point between the deck and your home’s framing. A failing ledger board puts the entire deck at risk of separation from the house. In pre-war Ardmore homes, ledger board failures are frequently discovered when what appeared to be a cosmetic deck repair is opened up to reveal deteriorated framing behind the siding. Ledger board failure always warrants a full replacement assessment.
If your existing deck is reaching the end of its life anyway, this is the opportunity to redesign the layout for how you actually use the space, incorporate features that were not part of the original design, and upgrade from aging pressure-treated wood to composite decking. Replacement is not just about addressing problems. It is also the moment to build what you actually want rather than preserving what was there.
Full deck replacement costs in the Philadelphia area range from $30 to $70 per square foot for the complete project. This is similar to a new installation because demolition and disposal costs offset the absence of new footing installation when existing footings can be reused.
When the existing structural frame is sound, board-only replacement is a cost-effective middle path that dramatically changes the appearance of the deck at a fraction of full replacement cost. Hynes Construction assesses whether your existing frame meets this standard honestly, not optimistically, because leaving a compromised frame in place under new boards is a problem that comes back quickly.
Deck repair is the right service when your Ardmore deck’s overall structure is sound but specific components have deteriorated, been damaged, or need attention for safety or aesthetic reasons. Good deck repair identifies the actual cause of the problem, addresses it at the root rather than the surface, and leaves the deck more reliable than before. Poor deck repair patches visible symptoms while leaving underlying causes in place, which produces the same problem in a new location within a season or two.
At Hynes Construction, we diagnose before we quote. We tell you what is actually wrong, why it happened, and what it will cost to fix properly. We do not recommend replacement when repair will genuinely solve the problem, and we do not recommend cosmetic repair on structural problems that will recur.
Individual deck boards rot most commonly at end cuts, around fastener holes where water infiltrates, and in sections that stay persistently wet due to the Ardmore tree canopy depositing debris that holds moisture against the surface. Replacing specific rotted boards while the underlying framing remains sound is a standard repair. We match existing board species and profile as closely as possible and fasten properly to the existing framing.
Cost: $300 to $1,500 depending on the number of boards and material. Composite board replacement runs higher because specialty decking fasteners and hidden clip systems are required to match the existing installation.
When rot or pest damage has affected a specific joist or beam but is truly localized, sistering (adding a new board alongside the damaged one) or replacing that single member is a viable repair. The key word is truly localized. If one joist is failing in an older deck, the adjacent joists are typically at similar risk and should be assessed honestly. We are conservative about partial structural repairs because a missed failing joist in an older Ardmore deck that carries load creates a safety issue.
Cost: $400 to $2,000 per structural member, depending on size, accessibility, and whether sistering or full replacement is required.
The ledger board connection between the deck and your Ardmore home is the most failure-prone component on older decks. Improper original flashing allows water to infiltrate behind the ledger, rotting both the ledger itself and the adjacent house framing. Ledger repair requires removing siding or trim to access the full connection, replacing deteriorated flashing, and reattaching the ledger with code-compliant hardware. This is not a surface repair. It requires opening up the connection fully.
Cost: $600 to $2,500, depending on the extent of deterioration and whether adjacent house framing needs repair.
Deck posts sit in post bases at ground level, and these connections deteriorate over time through moisture exposure and Pennsylvania’s freeze-thaw cycles. Deteriorated post bases allow posts to shift, which causes the deck to feel unstable. Individual post base replacement is a manageable repair when the post itself and the footing beneath it are sound. Sunken or heaved footings require more extensive work.
Cost: $200 to $700 per post for post-base repair. Footing replacement runs $400 to $1,200 per footing. -base
Loose railings are a safety issue, not an aesthetic one. Code-compliant deck railings must withstand 200 pounds of lateral force without failure. A wobbly railing on an Ardmore deck is a liability. Railing repair covers retightening loose connections, replacing deteriorated balusters, and reinforcing post connections. Full railing replacement becomes appropriate when the system has widespread deterioration or when an outdated system does not meet current code height requirements.
Cost: $150 to $500 for targeted railing repairs. Full railing replacement runs $20 to $250 per linear foot, depending on material, with composite and cable rail at the higher end.
Deck stairs are the highest-traffic component and frequently the first to deteriorate. Loose stair stringers, rotted treads, and failing stringer-to-deck connections are common repair calls. Wobbly stairs are a genuine fall risk, particularly for families with older adults or children. Stair repair on Ardmore decks often reveals that the framing below the deck at the stair attachment point has also deteriorated.
Cost: $500 to $2,500 for stair repair, depending on the number of stairs and the extent of structural involvement.
For wood decks whose surface has faded, weathered, or lost its protective finish but whose boards and structure remain sound, refinishing restores appearance and protection without the cost of board replacement. This involves cleaning, often with a deck-specific wash, sanding where needed to remove weathered surface fibers, and application of a penetrating stain or sealer. In Ardmore’s shaded backyard conditions, refinishing should be done every two to three years on wood decks to prevent premature deterioration.
Cost: $3 to $6.50 per square foot for professional deck refinishing, including cleaning and staining. A 200-square-foot deck runs $600 to $1,300.
Popped nails, deteriorated screws, and rusted joist hangers and post bases are common maintenance repairs. These seem minor, but are important because exposed fasteners create water infiltration points and loose boards create trip hazards. Fastener replacement is also frequently combined with refinishing during a maintenance visit.
Cost: $0.30 to $1.00 per square foot for fastener replacement across a full deck surface. Structural hardware replacement runs $50 to $300 per location.
Composite decking boards expand and contract with temperature changes. Decks installed without proper gap spacing or in conditions that caused boards to shift can develop contact points where boards are rubbing or edge heaving, where boards are pushing against each other. Gap correction for composite boards requires partially unclipping or removing boards, adjusting spacing, and resecuring. This is manufacturer-specification work that preserves the product warranty.
Cost: $200 to $800, depending on the extent of the gap issue and the length of the boarding that needs adjustment.
Many Ardmore decks were built without adequate waterproofing between the deck surface and the area beneath, particularly for second-story decks or decks above finished spaces. Water infiltrating through deck boards and damaging the area or room below is a specific problem we address with deck flashing systems and waterproof membrane installation. This pairs with our chimney repair and flashing expertise in terms of the waterproofing principles involved.
Cost: $500 to $3,000, depending on the size of the deck and the complexity of the waterproofing system required.
The decision between repair and replacement comes down to a straightforward financial and structural analysis:
We provide a free assessment and give you a written comparison of both options with honest costs for each. We will not push you toward replacement when repair will genuinely work, and we will not recommend repair on a deck that actually needs replacement just to offer a lower initial quote.
Ardmore’s signature mature oak and maple trees along Lancaster Avenue, Cricket Avenue, and throughout residential neighborhoods are one of the primary drivers of deck deterioration we see in this community. Shaded deck surfaces stay damp longer after rain, creating ideal conditions for mold, algae growth, and wood rot. Leaf accumulation in fall sits wet against deck boards for weeks if not cleared promptly, accelerating surface breakdown.
Composite decking resists these biological growth conditions significantly better than wood and is our recommendation for any Ardmore deck installation that will sit under a significant tree canopy. For existing wood decks, we recommend fall cleaning after peak leaf drop and spring refinishing as the minimum maintenance schedule to counteract these conditions.
Pennsylvania’s climate produces multiple freeze-thaw cycles per winter. Deck footings must be installed below the frost line, which is approximately 36 inches in the Ardmore area, to prevent heaving. Decks with footings at insufficient depth will shift, separate, and create structural hazards over time. When we assess an older Ardmore deck for replacement, footing depth is one of the first things we verify because shallow footings in our climate produce recurring structural problems regardless of what surface improvements are made.
Over 47 percent of Ardmore homes were built before 1939. These homes present specific challenges for deck ledger board attachment because the original exterior walls may use materials and construction methods that differ significantly from modern framing standards. Proper ledger board attachment in pre-war Ardmore homes requires understanding the specific wall assembly and using appropriate fasteners and flashing systems that account for the original construction. Hynes Construction has 50 years of experience with pre-war Main Line construction and knows how to handle these details correctly.
Several Ardmore neighborhoods have active civic associations with informal community expectations about exterior modifications. The North Ardmore Civic Association, South Ardmore Betterment Alliance, ArdWood Civic Association, and Ardmore Progressive Civic Association all maintain community standards that are worth being aware of before finalizing a deck design. Hynes Construction is familiar with the context in each of these neighborhoods and can advise on what designs are appropriate for your specific Ardmore location.
In Ardmore’s highly competitive real estate market, where homes sell in under 10 days, and median values exceed $597,000, the condition and quality of your deck directly affect both listing price and negotiation outcomes.
A new or recently replaced deck in good condition with quality composite materials and proper permits adds documented value. According to the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report for the Philadelphia region, wood decks deliver approximately 90 percent ROI at resale, and composite decks approximately 87 percent. Both figures significantly exceed national averages.
A deck in poor condition, with visible rot, unstable railings, missing boards, or obvious structural problems, creates negotiating leverage for buyers and can reduce your sale price by more than the cost of the repair would have been. Home inspectors flag deck conditions specifically, and buyers in Ardmore’s market are educated enough to know what a deck inspection report means.
If you are preparing to list your Ardmore home, a deck assessment and targeted repair or replacement is one of the highest-return pre-sale improvements you can make. The transferable GAF Golden Pledge Warranty that Hynes Construction offers on roofing work is a parallel documented asset, and buyers in this market respond well to documentation of professional, permitted improvements.
Deck projects frequently pair naturally with other exterior home improvements. Hynes Construction provides the full range: siding replacement including fiber cement and vinyl siding, window replacement, gutters and downspouts, gutter guards, exterior painting, chimney repairs, patio doors, storm doors, and the full range of roofing services. For comprehensive home improvement planning, see our other services page and speak with our team about coordinating multiple projects for maximum efficiency and value.
We provide deck installation, replacement, and repair throughout all of Ardmore, including North Ardmore, South Ardmore, Ardmore Park, Merion Golf Manor, and the ArdWood neighborhood. We serve both Lower Merion Township and Haverford Township addresses and surrounding communities, including Haverford, Bryn Mawr, Lower Merion, Wynnewood, Narberth, Havertown, Gladwyne, Devon, Paoli, and Villanova. See all areas we serve.
Also see: Ardmore home services | Ardmore dedicated page | Hynes Construction home page | About us | Blog.
Services in Ardmore
GET FREE ESTIMATE
Deck installation means building a new deck where one did not previously exist. Deck replacement means demolishing and removing an existing deck and building a completely new one in its place, typically because the old deck’s structural components have deteriorated beyond repair. Deck repair means fixing specific identified problems on an existing deck whose overall structure remains sound, such as replacing rotted boards, repairing railings, or addressing fastener failure. Hynes Construction handles all three services and will give you an honest assessment of which one applies to your situation.
Use the screwdriver test on accessible structural wood: push a screwdriver into posts, beams, and joists. If it sinks in more than one quarter inch with minimal resistance, the wood is rotted at a structural level, and replacement is likely the right answer. Surface rot on deck boards alone can often be a repair situation if the framing is sound. A deck that bounces underfoot, has a failing ledger board connection to the home, or is over 20 years old with multiple failing components is a replacement situation. Hynes Construction provides free assessments with written cost comparisons for both options.
Deck repair costs in Ardmore range widely, depending on the type and extent of damage. Individual rotted board replacement runs $300 to $1,500. Railing repairs run $150 to $500 for targeted fixes. Stair repair runs $500 to $2,500. Structural joist or beam repair runs $400 to $2,000 per member. Ledger board repair runs $600 to $2,500, depending on complexity. Deck refinishing (cleaning and restaining a wood deck) runs $600 to $1,300 for a 200-square-foot deck. Hynes Construction provides written estimates after a free inspection.
Full deck replacement in Ardmore ranges from $9,000 to $24,000 or more for a typical residential deck, depending on size, material choice, and design complexity. Pressure-treated wood replacement for a 200-square-foot deck runs approximately $9,000 to $15,000. Composite deck replacement for the square-foot size runs $15,000 to $24,000. Multi-level or complex designs add 20 to 40 percent over single-level costs. If only the surface boards need replacement while the structural frame is sound, board-only replacement costs $15 to $35 per square foot, which is significantly less than full replacement.
Pressure-treated wood decks in Pennsylvania typically last 15 to 25 years with proper maintenance. Cedar decks can last 20 to 30 years. Composite decks typically last 25 to 30 years or more, and most composite manufacturers warranty their products for 25 years. For Ardmore specifically, wood deck lifespan tends toward the shorter end of these ranges because of the dense tree canopy creating persistently moist, shaded conditions that accelerate biological growth and rot. Composite’s resistance to these conditions makes it a particularly practical choice for Ardmore backyards under significant tree cover.
Minor deck repairs, such as replacing individual boards, tightening fasteners, and refinishing, typically do not require permits in either Lower Merion Township or Haverford Township. Larger structural repairs involving ledger board replacement, footing work, or significant framing repair may require permits. Full deck replacement always requires a permit in both municipalities. Hynes Construction advises on permit requirements for every project and handles all permit applications when permits are required.
Yes, if the structural frame, meaning the posts, beams, joists, and ledger board, passes a thorough inspection with no evidence of significant rot, pest damage, or structural compromise. Board-only replacement is a cost-effective option that dramatically improves the deck’s appearance and adds years to its useful life. Hynes Construction assesses the existing frame honestly before recommending this approach, because installing new boards on a compromised frame just means the same problem comes back quickly.
Look for boards that are visually discolored or darkened, particularly around fastener holes where water collects. Boards that feel soft or spongy underfoot rather than firm. Boards showing splintering, cracking, or visible wood fiber separation. The screwdriver test: if you can press a screwdriver into the wood more than one-quarter inch with little resistance, the wood is rotted. Also, check end cuts where boards were cut to length, as these are the most vulnerable entry points for moisture.
For Ardmore specifically, composite is a particularly practical choice because the dense tree canopy in most Ardmore backyards creates persistently moist, shaded conditions that accelerate wood deterioration more than in sunnier environments. Composite resists mold, rot, and moisture far better than wood in these conditions. If you are replacing a deck with the primary goal of maximizing immediate resale value, pressure-treated wood delivers a slightly higher immediate ROI according to the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report. For homeowners staying in the home five or more years, composite’s maintenance savings and longevity typically make it the better total-cost investment.
Every two to three years for a wood deck in Ardmore, with the shorter interval applying to decks under significant tree canopy that stay shaded and damp for extended periods. Ardmore’s moist backyard conditions accelerate weathering on wood surfaces compared to decks in sunnier environments. Signs that refinishing is overdue include water that no longer beads on the surface, graying of the wood color, surface splintering, and loss of the previous stain or sealer coat. Spring is typically the best season to refinish because temperatures are moderate and humidity is reasonable.
I highly recommend Peter from Hynes Construction. He did work on the flat roof of my house and did a fabulous job. He is a very professional guy, great with follow up, answers your questions and gives great suggestions based on his experience, and Hynes construction is reasonably priced. Services: Power/pressure washing, Roof repair, Roof installation, Window cleaning.
Krissy helped me and provided a competitive quote for a new roof. After going through with 4 different quotes from other roofing companies, I decided Hynes Construction was the perfect company for the job. The roof looks beautiful and I am happy working with Hynes Team and I would recommend them to anyone doing a roof replacement! Services: Roof inspection, Roof installation, Roof repair
Hynes Construction did a fantastic job on my roof. Krissy was professional and easy to work with. They completed my large roof in a day. The crew worked very hard and cleaned up every bit of it. I am extremely happy with my decision of choosing Hynes Construction... Thanks a lot for a wonderful job well done. Services: Roof inspection, Roof installation, Skylight installation
They are quick. Handled everything in a proper way. Hynes Team did an amazing job and were very professional and friendly. They did a great job in cleaning. The work quality is fabulous and they offer competitive pricing. Professional and on time, I would definitely recommend Hynes Construction. Service: Window cleaning
Hynes is undoubtedly the best roofing company around! Professional and experts in what they do, they are clear and will guide you in a right way. I had a leak in my kitchen which another company told me I needed to replace the whole roof which I was too scared off. Later I called Hynes Team for second opinion and they were able to repair the roof and save me from spending thousands of dollars! So thankful for their honesty Services: Roof inspection, Storm / wind damage roof repair, Roof repair
Ridge and Peter both were wonderful and easy to work with. They took the time telling me about the work required and they both were very knowledgeable. I am sure Hynes Team and the company really take good care about the people they work with. I would highly recommend Hynes for any Roof replacement projects! Services: Roof inspection, Roof installation, Roof repair
Contacted Hynes Construction for some minor roof repairs. Hynes had someone out in no time and the repairs were done right after, they were really quick and delivered on time as they promised. I would definitely recommend them for your roofing needs! Thanks to Dan for getting our roof repaired and giving us peace of mind Service: Roof repair
For security purposes, please solve this simple puzzle to verify you are human before sending an OTP.